One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. LIVE IN PARADISE: Siesta Key Private Residence
Welcome to your own slice of paradise—an elevated, Key West–style home where mornings begin with dolphin sightings and evenings end in golden Gulf Coast sunsets. Custom-built in 2015 by Lee Wetherington and enhanced with over $500K in upgrades, this beautifully updated, turnkey residence blends modern comfort with island elegance.
A PRIVATE, SERENE SETTING
Tucked at the quiet end of a cul-de-sac in highly desirable Sara Sands, this elevated home offers privacy just moments from Siesta Key Beach—ranked #1 in the U.S. and #3 globally in 2025—and all the charm of Siesta Village. Whether strolling to dinner, biking the island, or paddleboarding from your dock, this location makes it easy to live the Florida dream.
INSPIRED DESIGN & NATURAL FLOW
Inside, discover 12-ft ceilings, rich wood floors, and an open-concept layout that unites the living, dining, and chef’s kitchen—outfitted with Thermador appliances, quartz countertops, and a walk-in pantry. The interiors invite connection and retreat, perfect for both casual mornings and elegant entertaining.
PRIMARY SUITE RETREAT + PRIVATE GUEST SPACES
The main-level primary suite offers spa-like serenity and abundant space, while two upstairs guest suites with ensuite baths ensure comfort and privacy for visitors.
INDOOR-OUTDOOR LIVING AT ITS BEST
Glass doors open to a covered lanai, heated saltwater pool and spa, and a full summer kitchen with built-in grill and prep sink. Your private dock with boat lift and fish-cleaning station opens to Gulf waters—ready for your next adventure.
PEACE OF MIND & PRACTICAL LUXURY
Hurricane-rated windows, new HVAC, fresh interior paint, and 10.5-ft elevated construction ensure durability and ease. A 3-car split garage provides room for hobbies, storage, or a golf cart. With no HOA, you’ll enjoy freedom to live your way.
A SMART CONDO ALTERNATIVE
For those seeking luxury island living with more space, more privacy, and fewer restrictions, this is the ideal alternative to condo life.
Some homes provide shelter.
This one inspires renewal.
Schedule your private showing today.
Welcome to your own slice of paradise—an elevated, Key West–style home where mornings begin with dolphin sightings and evenings end in golden Gulf Coast sunsets. Custom-built in 2015 by Lee Wetherington and enhanced with over $500K in upgrades, this beautifully updated, turnkey residence blends modern comfort with island elegance.
A PRIVATE, SERENE SETTING
Tucked at the quiet end of a cul-de-sac in highly desirable Sara Sands, this elevated home offers privacy just moments from Siesta Key Beach—ranked #1 in the U.S. and #3 globally in 2025—and all the charm of Siesta Village. Whether strolling to dinner, biking the island, or paddleboarding from your dock, this location makes it easy to live the Florida dream.
INSPIRED DESIGN & NATURAL FLOW
Inside, discover 12-ft ceilings, rich wood floors, and an open-concept layout that unites the living, dining, and chef’s kitchen—outfitted with Thermador appliances, quartz countertops, and a walk-in pantry. The interiors invite connection and retreat, perfect for both casual mornings and elegant entertaining.
PRIMARY SUITE RETREAT + PRIVATE GUEST SPACES
The main-level primary suite offers spa-like serenity and abundant space, while two upstairs guest suites with ensuite baths ensure comfort and privacy for visitors.
INDOOR-OUTDOOR LIVING AT ITS BEST
Glass doors open to a covered lanai, heated saltwater pool and spa, and a full summer kitchen with built-in grill and prep sink. Your private dock with boat lift and fish-cleaning station opens to Gulf waters—ready for your next adventure.
PEACE OF MIND & PRACTICAL LUXURY
Hurricane-rated windows, new HVAC, fresh interior paint, and 10.5-ft elevated construction ensure durability and ease. A 3-car split garage provides room for hobbies, storage, or a golf cart. With no HOA, you’ll enjoy freedom to live your way.
A SMART CONDO ALTERNATIVE
For those seeking luxury island living with more space, more privacy, and fewer restrictions, this is the ideal alternative to condo life.
Some homes provide shelter.
This one inspires renewal.
Schedule your private showing today.
Property Details
Price:
$3,288,000
MLS #:
A4641428
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
3.5
Address:
5169 SANDY SHORE AVENUE
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
SARA SANDS
Neighborhood:
34242 – Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
City:
SARASOTA
Listed Date:
Feb 27, 2025
State:
FL
Finished Sq Ft:
4,678
Total Sq Ft:
4,678
ZIP:
34242
Lot Size:
13,415 sqft / 0.31 acres (approx)
Year Built:
2015
Schools
Elementary School:
Phillippi Shores Elementary
Middle School:
Brookside Middle
High School:
Sarasota High
Interior
Appliances
Built- In Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer, Water Filtration System, Water Softener, Wine Refrigerator
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms, 1 Half Bathroom
Cooling
Central Air, Humidity Control, Zoned
Flooring
Engineered Hardwood, Tile
Heating
Electric, Propane
Laundry Features
Laundry Room
Exterior
Architectural Style
Coastal, Florida, Key West
Construction Materials
Concrete, Stone, Stucco, Wood Frame
Exterior Features
French Doors, Irrigation System, Outdoor Kitchen, Outdoor Shower, Rain Gutters, Sliding Doors
Parking Features
Circular Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Split Garage, Workshop in Garage
Roof
Metal
Security Features
Security System, Smoke Detector(s)
Financial
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$27,601
Map
Community
- Address5169 SANDY SHORE AVENUE SARASOTA FL
- SubdivisionSARA SANDS
- CitySARASOTA
- CountySarasota
- Zip Code34242
Similar Listings Nearby
- 3939 HIGEL AVENUE
SARASOTA, FL$4,250,000
1.42 miles away
- 810 SIESTA DRIVE
SARASOTA, FL$4,250,000
1.74 miles away
- 603 TREMONT ST
SARASOTA, FL$4,249,000
0.58 miles away
- 1354 WESTWAY DRIVE
SARASOTA, FL$4,185,000
4.01 miles away
- 3916 N SHELL ROAD
SARASOTA, FL$4,175,000
1.53 miles away
- 1543 EASTBROOK DRIVE
SARASOTA, FL$4,000,000
1.79 miles away
Courtesy of WATERSIDE REALTY LLC. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Stellar MLS. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CENTURY 21 Carioti include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor CENTURY 21 Carioti shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2025. Stellar MLS. All rights reserved. 5169 SANDY SHORE AVENUE
SARASOTA, FL
LIGHTBOX-IMAGES